Joel Tan

Queer Singapore: Empire Is Not That Far Away”

This personal essay teases out the homophobic colonial legacies that continue to bind Singapore and the United Kingdom.

published in

daikon* Issue #5: Summer 2018 / Migration → issuu.com <https://issuu.com/daikonzine/docs/summer-migration>

Excerpt

At a dinner party in Buckingham, I meet an elderly British man who, on learning that I’m from Singapore, tells me he was stationed there with the British navy in the 60s. He winks and asks me if I know about Bugis Street, a part of town infamous at the time for its transgender sex-workers and licentious foreign sailors. The number of times I’ve been asked this question.

I don’t answer him. But I start to think about my father, himself a sailor in his youth, a man descended from immigrants from Hainan Island in Southern China. 

I think of a little factoid the colonial historian Malcolm Turnbull once turned up about how, in the mid 19th century, fair-skinned, good-looking boys from Hainan Island were shipped over by the British to serve as prostitutes for other Chinese workers and possibly British settlers. 

I think about fluid East Asian attitudes towards queer desire, how Hainanese men in particular were known for their femininity, their openness towards homosexuality. In French Indochina, Chinese houseboys, many of them Hainanese like me, were known as “ambassadors of sodomy”. In Singapore, the Chinese houseboys who served the British were overwhelmingly Hainanese. We were known for our cooking, the gentleness of our approach. 

I think of the frissons and desires that must have sprung between masters and servants in those dank, sweaty tropical houses; forbidden issuances left out of the history books.

I think about how much of the fetish for other skin must have been learned in the fetid, unequal crucible of the colonial encounter.

There is much in common between the man on Grindr seeking smooth-skinned, submissive bottoms from Far East Asia, and a certain Charles Baker, the early 20th century gentleman traveler and cocktail enthusiast, who writes, in his description of the Singapore Sling at the Raffles Hotel:

“When our soft-footed Malay boy brings the 4th Sling and finds us peering over the window sill at the cobra-handling snakecharmers tootling their confounded flutes below, he murmurs 'jaga baik-baik Tuan' . . . or 'take care master' as it means in English. The Singapore Gin Sling is a delicious, slow-acting, insidious thing.”

I think of these spiritual inheritances from long-dead queer ancestors, a queer history recorded as forgotten lovers, censored names, inscriptions on the heart and imagination.



Fat Shame”

Approaching the shame of inhabiting a fat body from the lens of economics, queer performance, and Singapore’s autocratic political culture, this chapbook is accompanied by a portrait series of the writer in drag.

published IN

Discipline The City Issue 04: Fat Shame / 2017 → The Substation <http://www.substation.org/dtc-publication-issue-04>

Excerpt

Unsurprisingly, my earliest memories of shame have to do with my fatness, constituted from an endless list of daily humiliations, much of it to do with institutional processes and well-intentioned but callous adults. This shame is better regulated but still present today. Now an adult, I realise I have internalised a range of ways to be ashamed of my fat. I’m constantly aware of how my curves protrude extraneously from the average male silhouette. I still have the habitual tic of pulling down a t-shirt that has  ridden up into a fold on my body. Often, I experience and repress the shame of being seen eating in public. I endure people trying to address my weight in casual conversation, cutting off “obese” mid-word as an embarrassed kindness.

The most universal experience of fat seems to be shame. It presses in on you from culture: The willful exclusion of fatness from beauty; the willful inclusion of fatness in discussions of epidemics; the well-meaning concern of friends and family; the mixed guilt and enjoyment of eating food.

It’s one thing to wax self-pityingly about daily micro-aggressions, but it is more productive to ask: Why is fat so shameful? It’s a simple provocation, but a rich one. Why is so much contemporary culture fixated on fat as an object of shame?

Shame is a relational property. It always implies other people. Shame doesn’t exist in isolation from the scorn of others. Shame suggests discipline and discipliners, a collective willing into invisibility or non-existence of something that is aberrant, unsightly, offensive and embarrassing.

One of the most profound forms of shame is what the Germans call fremdschämen, the cringing shame you feel when you witness someone else embarrassing themselves. Fremnd means “foreign” or “strange”. You feel this alien, implicating shame for another as if by spiritual possession. You undergo an almost out-of-body experience, a profound but unwanted experience of empathy.

Fremdschämen was the shame of my auntie at a food emporium one day when I was a child. She stared pityingly at me, chubby-armed, reaching out to a shop assistant’s platter of chocolate samples. My auntie clucked her tongue and declared, “No wonder you’re so fat.” My face flushed, my eyes met hers, and I saw an instant flash of regret on her face. Shame bound my auntie and me as I retracted my hand and pulled my gaze away from the kindly shop assistant. I averted my eyes from my auntie’s the rest of the outing. We never spoke of it again.



21994389_1778317752199161_753916547753026007_o.jpg

We Could Have Danced All Night”

The closing of Singapore gay night club, Play, occasions a meditation on the high-highs and pitfalls of queer dancing, romancing, and loneliness in the city.

published IN

Poskod.sg, Singapore, 2015

Excerpt

The first time I saw strobe lights was at Play. That’s probably not true. But the first strobe lights I truly remember, green lasers that burned themselves into the back of my head, were at Play. They back-lit a man dancing in that way gay men dance: beautifully, with self-conscious un-self-consciousness. I was entranced. It was before the club updated its light fixtures, back when it was dark and truly seedy, and all I could see was that shadowed mass dancing in his little hotspot like a junked-up Green Fairy, dancing for what seemed to be hours in my liquored judgment. It was probably only one song. I never saw his face. And in a blast of chemical haze from a cheap smoke machine, he was gone.

In a similarly entrancing way, Play the Gay Club and Bar, has gone. A few weeks before it shut down its Tanjong Pagar Road premises (saying this suggests there will be another premises), there was a shocking social media announcement, met by disbelieving, mournful hashtags. The space has most likely been ceded to an upscale restaurant—one of several encroaching on the area from Tras, Duxton and Ann Siang—that offered double or triple the rent. In a dignified manner, in Play’s final weekends, those who cared snaked around it to pay tribute. Old hens and cocks turned up for one last claw-scratch on the storied dancefloor, the boi bois and ger gers chanted and perspired inappropriately to the end, the bar ran out of alcohol, the front of house nonetheless charged cover, the lights came on, and a week later, it was all gutted, fetid queer trace elements flung out to compost in the seedy Tanjong Pagar streets.

A Substanial Man”

An interrogation of gay male body culture, shot through with personal reflections on shame, self-worth, and fat politics. 

published IN

Poskod.sg, Singapore, 2015

Excerpt

There is, to my mind, a gay man’s debutante ball, except it’s quite DIY. Leisurely, at one’s own pace, coming out can be awkward or beautiful, ostentatious or quiet, but it’s a ritual all the same. I was wearing a black shirt, I remember, and I was introduced by my best friend, learned in the ways of gay principalities, to the bars, to the clubs… that district at Tanjong Pagar where men wear tight shorts and hold hands and make out in public, where, in 2008, the air was electric with glances exchanged over traffic crossings, with Top 40s music, with a gurgling of men.

There was for me a sense of breaking through thresholds: between in and out, gay and homosexual, lonely and not, me and you. I’d been gay before 2008, for sure, but that night, I started to learn that being gay works for many people in a much more abstract sense than simply loving men. It’s an energy, a buzzing, silent nomenclature: in Tanjong Pagar, people spoke in clothing, in hairstyles, in the company they kept, in the glances they gave, in the glances they received.

If gayness is a language, it’s a language I’ve never been fluent in. I’ve found that this is because it’s often a language spoken through bodies, and some bodies negotiate it better than others. In a world composed of images, one body in particular rules over it. It is the gym fit body, that perverse paradigm which so commands the gay imagination.